Sara is delighted to hear the story of a long-ago suitor of Marilla Cuthbert's named Duncan McTavish. When Sara discovers that a Duncan McTavish has arrived in Avonlea, she rushes to share this news with Marilla--not realizing she has caught Marilla in a lie.

When Aunt Arabella's hope chest is opened, nothing of value is found. But Sara is sure something important is hidden there, and enlists the aid of Aunt Olivia to solve the mystery.

Rachel Lynde thinks her toothache is going to kill her, but in all reality the two orphans Marilla has taken in and the uncovering of a youthful romance might do it.

The return of Roger King, famous geologist, fills the King family with excitement, but a boyhood feud between Roger and his brother Alec fares up again and wreaks havoc on the whole family.

When hockey becomes the sport on Prince Edward Island, many feuds and spats escalate between friends until one game settles them all.

Sara decides her life is not so bad after trading places with look-alike pickpocket, Jo Pitts.

Sara and her cousin Felicity King are watching the children of the town, when petty arguments nearly ruin their day, but when one little boy is missing, in the search to find him they put their differences aside.