Mary Lou has taken it upon herself to help the remaining Fuller boys find suitable wives, but her plans to matchmake Samuel, the fifth Fuller brother, go horribly wrong. Samuel has always had his heart set on one girl, Catherine Miller. He knows if he doesn't make move soon, someone else will. He soon learns that there is more than his shyness standing in his way of happiness. Now that people are learning of the secret within the Fuller family, will that harm Samuel's chances with Catherine?